reply-context-examples

 reply context examples  are real-world examples of reply-contexts on both indieweb sites and silos, how they are presented, their visual design & UI, both on permalinks & in-stream.

Add Examples
Please add examples!

If you support reply-contexts on your site, please take a screenshot of a particularly good example (the nicer looking the better, though any example is good), upload it to the wiki, and add a subsection for yourself in the "IndieWeb Examples" section below.

If you see a nice reply-context design on a silo, take a screenshot of it, upload it, and document it in the Silo Examples section. It's ok to document multiple examples per silo as sometimes they change their UI over time and it's helpful to see what design iterations they've gone through.

Aaron Parecki
uses p3k which shows reply-contexts for replies on aaronparecki.com:

reply to a note
Reply context with original post text (auto-linked), dt-published (linked to original post permalink), author name/photo/URL:




 * http://aaronparecki.com/replies/2013/04/19/2/indieweb
 * http://aaronparecki.com/replies/2013/04/25/1/indieweb-qs

reply to a deleted note

 * http://aaronparecki.com/replies/2014/05/17/1/ is a reply to a tweet which was later deleted. Instead the reply-context shows and links to the IRC log of the deleted tweet.

multireplies
IndieWeb examples of displaying a reply to multiple other posts
 * http://aaronparecki.com/replies/2013/04/21/1/
 * http://aaronparecki.com/replies/2012/12/05/15/leweb

Barnaby Walters
on waterpigs.co.uk:

Reply context with original post text (@-names auto-linked), dt-published (displayed as relative time, and linked to original post permalink), author name/photo (both linked to author URL)



Tantek
undefined on tantek.com: example reply context with original post permalink displayed and linked:



Example on tantek.com of a of displaying a reply to multiple other posts

Multi-reply to four tweets:
 * http://tantek.com/2013/157/t3/pdf2013-third-rail-coffee-during-pdf13-break

In-stream reply-contexts on tantek.com since 2018-05-02.
 * (screenshots needed / before & after)

Ben Werdmuller
on werd.io, using idno's reply context presentation:

Reply context is shown with a "reply" arrow/icon, followed with the text "Replied to a post on ", then the domain of the original post, e.g. "bret.io", and finally a colon ":", where "a post on {domain}:" is hyperlinked to the URL of the original post. This feature was introduced on June 24, 2013.



Multiple reply contexts are also possible:

Kartik Prabhu
(as of 2014-04-30) Reply context shows a "In reply to" caption followed by a list of hyperlinked urls of the original post.



gRegor Morrill
as of 2015-12-26, reply context shows the author photo, author name, author URL, original post link, and plaintext content. Examples:
 * http://gregorlove.com/2015/07/solution-or-go-home-couldnt/ [[File:gregorlove-reply-context-2015-12-26.png]]
 * reply to a public tweet: http://gregorlove.com/2015/12/and-thanks-for-all-the/
 * reply to a private tweet: http://gregorlove.com/2015/12/girlvsplanet-thanks/

Previously: As of 2014-06-25, reply context shows "In reply to a [post on domain]," with "post on domain" being a link to the original post.

Example from http://gregorlove.com/notes/2014/06/26/1/



Greg
Greg displays photos in reply contexts, from https://unrelenting.technology/replies/2017-01-06-17-05-01



capjamesg
displays the following pieces of information in reply context boxes (when such information is available to retrieve):


 * Article title
 * Author (fallback to domain on which content was published)
 * Article description
 * Author icon

James' Micropub client first aims to retrieve this information using h-entry and h-card markup. If this markup is not available, the client will aim to extract the information above (excluding author icon) using another method.



Jacky
uses Koype which attempts to capture as much information about the remote URL that can be used for a reply context as such but not limited to:


 * Author information (to build as complete as a h-card as possible)
 * Tags, syndication information, alternate URLs
 * Media like videos, picture and audio markup

It happens first using native MF2 parsing, failing that sending the URL through pipes and if that doesn't work, building a "synthetic" representation of the MF2 from things like,   and.

Jamie Tanna
uses a mix of pipes services to retrieve a Microformats2 cite of a post, which is then stored in his site, and used to render the reply context.

For instance:

- context for a Twitter interaction https://www.jvt.me/mf2/2022/03/b9kel/ - context using OpenGraph https://www.jvt.me/mf2/2022/03/6baq0/ - context using Microformats2 https://www.jvt.me/mf2/2022/03/k2e5x/

Past Examples
Past IndieWeb examples where the permalinks either no longer work or no longer display the reply post.

Sandeep Shetty
On sandeep.io:

Reply context with original post text (using the site-wide consistent blockquote convention for quoting external content), author name (linked to author URL) and link to original post permalink. I used to also show dt-published and author photo (similar to this like-context: http://indiewebcamp.com/File:sandeep.io-like-example.png) but redesigned it to emphasize content.



Bret
Bret.io used to show reply contexts with a "reply" arrow/icon, followed with the text "Replied to a post on ", then the domain of the original post, e.g. "werd.io", and finally a colon ":", where "a post on {domain}:" is hyperlinked to the URL of the original post.

This reply context presentation was modeled after idno as a way to get something working quickly. Still very much in development.



(link appears to 404 as of 2022)

Kyle Mahan
used Red Wind to show reply contexts on kylewm.com replies to others' notes since 2014-10-16 (needs permalink and preferably earlier/earliest example):



And photo reply contexts on replies to others' photos since (at least?) 2014-05-07:
 * https://kylewm.com/2014/05/i-used-to-live-in-bernal-heights-when-i-lived-in-the-city-looks-like

(kylewm.com permalinks 404 as of 2022)

reply to a photo
Mockup by of how a reply-context in-reply-to a photo post could show a thumbnail of that photo:


 * Actual live post this mockup is based on: http://aaronparecki.com/replies/2013/04/30/3/
 * Note: it's a reply to a post on instagram.com
 * Reply to a photo-post on an indieweb site: http://aaronparecki.com/replies/2014/07/08/1/

Twitter profile page
2018-03-03: On profile pages, when you choose Tweets & Replies, the replies show a minimal reply-context in-stream:



Twitter home page
Twitter's home page shows in-stream reply-contexts.

As of 2018-03-05 or earlier:

Example of a retweet of a reply (possibly the only time you see replies in-stream on Twitter home stream)



Note all the info packed into this display:
 * who retweeted
 * reply author and dt-published
 * reply-context
 * reply content
 * link-preview
 * reply/retweet/like webactions with counts

Quote of a reply tweet example:



Note the reply-context is inside the quoted box along with the rest of the quoted reply.

2013-08-29 Update: As of today Twitter in-stream reply-contexts have gone live:
 * https://about.twitter.com/products/conversations

Starting 2013-06-03 (and ending sometime before 2013-07-23) it appears that Twitter (for some subset of users) was showing reply contexts for @-replies even when the replies are displayed *inline* in a stream!



If the tweet being replied to is itself a reply to another tweet that is the start of the thread, all three are shown:

From 2013-06-03..2013-06-05:

As of 2013-06-06 (and ending sometime before 2013-07-23) there was a vertical ellipsis and a "View conversation" link that goes to the permalink of the tweet of the start of the thread: "View conversation" - live copy of hyperlink in screenshots example.

Twitter collapses a longer threaded reply-context down to the start of the thread, a "View n more tweets" link, the tweet that's being replied to, and finally, the @-reply itself:



"View 3 more tweets" goes to the permalink of the start of the thread, it does not expand it in-place. Seems like reasonable behavior.

As of 2013-05-27, Twitter is using this reply context UI within email notifications spam:




 * I find the constant flips in the directionality of time on twitter.com confusing. First swapping from feed -> permalink page, now there are mini reversed feeds *within* the main feed — is it just me or is it not always obvious (especially in long conversations) which direction the conversation is moving in? --Waterpigs.co.uk 09:22, 5 June 2013 (PDT)
 * There is definitely a context-switch that happens. Not as jarring to me but consistency would be good. --Kartik Prabhu 23:30, 30 April 2014 (CDT)