Apple ID

From IndieWeb
Jump to: navigation, search


Apple ID is a universal identity system from Apple that they use on iOS and macOS systems as well as their iCloud service.

Warnings

  • If you have an existing AppleID *without* a phone number, DO NOT associate a phone number to it as you won't be able to de-associate it later (without adding another phone number). See: Criticism: Inability to remove a phone number

Criticism

Fearmongering Security UI

Apple ID, in particular on MacOS 10.13 High Sierra, presents a very scary dialog if you don't go along with their TFA prompting (which just happens to force you to use SMS for TFA).

2017-11-15-macos-2fa-sms-fear-alert.png

You literally have to choose the scarier option "Don't Upgrade" if you want to avoid / postpone / never setup SMS as your second factor.

See related: SMS#Apple_ID

Requires a phone number to create

As of 2022 (perhaps earlier), creating a new AppleID requires a phone number that can receive a text message or a phone call.

Inability to remove a phone number

As of 2022 (perhaps earlier), once you add a phone number to an AppleID (which Apple prompts you to do every time you upgrade your iOS or MacOS, see previous screenshots), you cannot remove it if it is the only number connected to the AppleID.

Does not support TOTP

Unlike Google Account, AppleID lack the ability to use a TOTP application for multi-factor authentication, thus depending on a (much more vulnerable) phone number.

See Also